Insights
Most businesses spend everything chasing new ones. The ones already coming through your door are worth more than you think.
We walked into a restaurant last fall. The owner was proud, and he should have been. Packed from Memorial Day through Labor Day. Tables turned twice most nights. Best season in years.
We asked one question: how many of those people have you talked to since?
He looked at us like we'd asked him in a different language.
This is the most common thing we see in tourist-economy businesses. Incredible foot traffic. Real, paying customers who liked it enough to come in, who told their friends, who took photos and left reviews. And almost no way to reach any of them after they walked out the door.
They drove up from downstate. They came from Chicago. They found you on Google Maps or a recommendation from the place down the road. They had a great time. And then they were gone. And so was any chance you had of being part of the plan when they came back next year.
This is not a technology problem. It is not a marketing budget problem. It is a habit problem. And it costs more than most owners realize.
Here is the math, rough as it is. If your average transaction is worth $80 and a repeat customer comes back twice in a season instead of once, that is $80 in revenue that cost you almost nothing. No ad spend. No platform cut. No new customer acquisition cost at all. Just a person who already liked you, coming back because you stayed in front of them.
Multiply that across 200 customers who opted in to hear from you. That is $16,000 in potential revenue sitting in a list you have not built yet. Most businesses we talk to have never tried to calculate this because they have never tried to capture it. They are spending time and money chasing new customers while the ones they already have are waiting to be asked back.
It is not laziness. Running a food and beverage operation or a tourist-economy business is genuinely hard. You are managing staff and inventory and the hundred things that go sideways on a Friday night in August when you are at capacity. Building a customer list feels like a project for some future version of you who has more time.
The problem is that version never shows up. The season ends. You close for winter or shift to off-season hours. You start planning for next year. And when May comes back around, you are starting from scratch with foot traffic again instead of opening the season with a few hundred people who already know you and already have plans to come north.
This does not require a complicated system. It requires a habit and a reason for people to say yes.
Ask during the experience, not at checkout. When someone is having a great time they are much more likely to want to stay connected. Give them something worth opting into. Early access. A locals-and-loyalists discount in the shoulder season when you need traffic most. A short note at the start of each summer about what is new. It does not have to be elaborate. It has to be consistent and worth opening.
Three emails a year will do more than you think. One in May to say you are opening. One in July with something worth sharing. One in October to close the season and stay in their heads over the winter. That is three chances to be the first place they think of when they are planning the next trip up.
The tourist economy is more crowded than it used to be. There are more options. More places competing for the same summer weekend. Standing out increasingly means having a relationship with your customers rather than just a transaction with them.
The businesses we have watched do this well are not doing anything technically sophisticated. They are just consistently showing up for people who showed up for them first. That is the whole thing.
If you have never tried to build a customer list, the best time to start is before your next season opens. The second best time is right now. Either way, it starts with pausing long enough to look at what you already have. We can help you figure out where to begin.
← Back to Insights